What Are Oil and Gas Royalties?

Oil and gas royalties represent a share of the revenue generated from the production of oil and natural gas on a specific piece of land or mineral estate, paid to the owner of the mineral rights without the burden of operational costs or management responsibilities. Here’s a closer look:

• Mineral Rights Ownership: When you own mineral rights (separate from surface rights in many cases), you have the legal right to extract or lease the extraction of oil, gas, or other minerals beneath the land. If you lease those rights to an energy company, they handle the drilling and production, and you receive a royalty—typically a percentage of the revenue (often 12.5% to 25%) from the extracted resources.
• Passive Income: Royalties are considered a passive investment because the mineral rights owner doesn’t have to manage the drilling, maintenance, or operational risks. The energy company covers those costs, and you simply collect payments based on production.
• Types of Royalties:
  • Overriding Royalty Interest (ORRI): A royalty carved out of the working interest (the operator’s share), often temporary and tied to a specific lease.
  • Non-Participating Royalty Interest (NPRI): A royalty that doesn’t include decision-making rights in leasing or operations, just a right to revenue.
  • Mineral Royalty: Direct ownership of mineral rights, giving the owner more control over leasing decisions.
• Revenue Factors: Payments depend on production volume, market prices for oil and gas, and the terms of the lease. If production slows or prices drop, royalty income can decrease.

For example, if you own mineral rights on a 100-acre plot in Texas, you might lease those rights to an oil company. They drill, produce 1,000 barrels of oil a month, and sell it at $70 per barrel. With a 20% royalty rate, you’d earn $14,000 a month (1,000 barrels × $70 × 20%).

Oil and Gas Royalties in a 1031 Exchange

A 1031 exchange allows investors to defer capital gains taxes by selling one investment property and reinvesting the proceeds into a “like-kind” property. Oil and gas royalties can qualify as a 1031 exchange investment vehicle because they are considered real property under IRS rules, but there are specific nuances to understand.

Why Oil and Gas Royalties Qualify as Like-Kind Property

• Real Property Classification: The IRS treats mineral rights, including oil and gas royalties, as real property because they’re tied to the land and its subsurface resources. This makes them eligible for a 1031 exchange when swapped for other real property, such as another mineral interest, a rental property, or a Delaware Statutory Trust (DST) interest.
• Like-Kind Flexibility: The “like-kind” requirement in a 1031 exchange is broad for real estate. You can exchange oil and gas royalties for other types of real estate (e.g., a commercial building) as long as both are held for investment or business purposes. For instance, you could sell royalty rights in Oklahoma and buy a shopping center in Florida.

How to Use Oil and Gas Royalties in a 1031 Exchange

Here’s the step-by-step process of using oil and gas royalties in a 1031 exchange:

1. Sell the Royalties (Relinquished Property): You decide to sell your oil and gas royalty interest. Let’s say you own royalty rights valued at $1 million, with a basis of $400,000, meaning you’d owe taxes on a $600,000 gain if you didn’t do an exchange.
2. Engage a Qualified Intermediary (QI): You hire a QI to hold the proceeds from the sale, ensuring you don’t take constructive receipt of the funds (which would trigger taxes).
3. Identify Replacement Property: Within 45 days of the sale, you identify up to three replacement properties. This could be another oil and gas royalty interest, a different type of mineral interest (like coal or gravel), or any other investment real estate, such as a warehouse or DST.
4. Purchase the Replacement Property: Within 180 days of the sale, you use the $1 million in proceeds to buy the replacement property. To fully defer taxes, the replacement property must be of equal or greater value and debt than the sold royalty interest.
5. Defer Capital Gains Taxes: By completing the exchange, you defer the $600,000 capital gains tax, keeping the full $1 million working in your new investment.

Examples of 1031 Exchanges with Oil and Gas Royalties

• Royalty to Royalty: You sell a $500,000 oil royalty interest in the Permian Basin and buy a $600,000 gas royalty interest in the Marcellus Shale.
• Royalty to Traditional Real Estate: You sell a $1 million royalty interest and buy a $1.2 million apartment building.
• Royalty to DST: You sell a $2 million mineral royalty and invest in a DST that owns a portfolio of office buildings, allowing for more passive management.

Benefits of Using Oil and Gas Royalties in a 1031 Exchange

• Tax Deferral: You avoid paying capital gains taxes on the sale of your royalty interest, which can be significant given the appreciation potential of mineral rights in productive areas.
• Portfolio Diversification: You can transition from a volatile royalty investment (tied to oil and gas prices) to a more stable real estate asset, like a commercial property with steady rental income.
• Passive Income Continuity: If you exchange into another royalty interest or a DST, you maintain a passive income stream without the operational headaches of managing a property.
• Flexibility: The broad like-kind definition lets you shift into different real estate sectors or geographic markets, optimizing your investment strategy.

Challenges and Considerations

• Valuation Complexity: Oil and gas royalties can be tricky to value because their worth depends on future production estimates, commodity prices, and lease terms. You’ll need a professional appraisal to ensure compliance with 1031 rules.
• Market Volatility: Royalty income fluctuates with oil and gas prices. If you’re exchanging into another royalty interest, you’re still exposed to that volatility.
• Depletion Risk: Oil and gas reserves are finite. A royalty interest might decline in value over time as the resource is extracted, unlike traditional real estate, which may appreciate.
• IRS Scrutiny on Intent: The IRS requires that both the relinquished and replacement properties be held for investment. If you sell a royalty interest and buy another with the intent to flip it quickly, the IRS might disallow the exchange.
• Timing and Rules: Like any 1031 exchange, you must adhere to the 45-day identification and 180-day closing deadlines, and all proceeds must go through a QI.

Special Considerations for Oil and Gas Royalties

• Working Interests vs. Royalties: A working interest in an oil and gas operation (where you’re responsible for operational costs) doesn’t qualify as like-kind for a 1031 exchange because it’s considered a business interest, not real property. Royalties, however, are passive and qualify.
• State-Specific Laws: Mineral rights and royalties are governed by state law, which can affect how they’re valued or transferred. For example, in Texas, mineral rights are often severed from surface rights, while in other states, they may be bundled.
• Depletion Deduction: Royalty owners can often claim a depletion deduction on their taxes, reducing taxable income from the royalty payments. This tax benefit carries over if you exchange into another royalty interest but may not apply to other real estate types.

Real-World Context

Oil and gas royalties have been particularly appealing in regions like the Permian Basin, Bakken Shale, or Marcellus Shale, where production has boomed in recent years. As of early 2025, with oil prices fluctuating around $70-$80 per barrel (based on recent market trends), royalty interests remain a lucrative investment, but their volatility pushes some investors to use 1031 exchanges to diversify into more stable assets. For instance, an investor in North Dakota might sell a royalty interest tied to a declining oil well and exchange into a DST owning a portfolio of medical office buildings, trading commodity risk for predictable rental income.

In summary, oil and gas royalties are a passive income stream from mineral rights that qualify as real property for a 1031 exchange, allowing investors to defer taxes while transitioning into other investment properties. They offer flexibility and tax advantages but come with unique risks tied to resource depletion and market volatility, making them a strategic choice for investors looking to balance income, diversification, and tax planning.

We love helping investors take the next step. Please don’t hesitate to call us – we have 1031 Specialists ready to answer your questions just one phone call away at (949) 328-6744.

If you’re ready to start looking at properties online, create an account below to get started: