What Alternative Investments can be Identified as like-kind Property?

A 1031 exchange under Section 1031 of the U.S. Internal Revenue Code allows investors to defer capital gains taxes by exchanging one investment property for another “like-kind” property. While 1031 exchanges are most commonly associated with real estate, the “like-kind” definition can extend to certain alternative investment vehicles, as long as they are classified as real property under IRS rules. However, excluding traditional real estate (like buildings, land, or rental properties) narrows the scope significantly, because most non-real estate assets—like stocks, bonds, or personal property—don’t qualify for a 1031 exchange following changes in the tax code. The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 limited 1031 exchanges to real property only, eliminating personal property (e.g., equipment, vehicles, or artwork) from eligibility.

That said, there are still some alternative investment vehicles that can qualify as “real property” for a 1031 exchange, even if they aren’t traditional real estate. Below, I’ll describe a few options that fit within the IRS’s definition of real property, focusing on assets that are tied to land or resource rights, as well as certain leasehold interests.

1. Mineral Rights (Including Oil and Gas Royalties)

• What They Are: Mineral rights grant the owner the ability to extract or lease the extraction of subsurface resources like oil, gas, coal, or minerals (e.g., gravel, gold). Royalties are a passive income stream derived from leasing those rights to an operator who handles production.
• Why They Qualify: The IRS considers mineral rights and associated royalty interests as real property because they are inherently tied to the land. This makes them eligible for a 1031 exchange when swapped for other real property.
• How They’re Used in a 1031 Exchange: You can sell mineral rights or royalty interests and reinvest the proceeds into another like-kind real property. For example, you could exchange oil and gas royalties in Texas for a different mineral interest (like coal rights in West Virginia) or even traditional real estate (like a commercial building).
• Benefits:
  • Passive income from royalty payments without operational responsibilities.
  • Potential for high returns if the resource is in a productive area.
  • Diversification away from traditional real estate while staying within 1031 rules.
• Risks:
  • Volatility tied to commodity prices (e.g., oil prices can fluctuate widely).
  • Depletion risk, as resources are finite and production may decline over time.
  • Valuation can be complex, requiring professional appraisals.

2. Timber Rights

• What They Are: Timber rights give the owner the right to harvest trees on a specific parcel of land for commercial purposes, such as lumber or paper production. These rights can be leased to timber companies, generating income over time.
• Why They Qualify: Timber rights are considered real property because they are directly tied to the land and its natural resources. The IRS has historically treated standing timber (trees not yet cut) as part of the real estate, making timber rights eligible for a 1031 exchange.
• How They’re Used in a 1031 Exchange: You can sell timber rights and exchange them for another real property asset. For example, you might sell timber rights on a 500-acre forest in Oregon and reinvest the proceeds into mineral rights in Montana or a rental property.
• Benefits:
  • Sustainable income potential if the timber is managed responsibly (e.g., through reforestation).
  • Exposure to the growing demand for timber in construction and manufacturing.
  • Can be a hedge against inflation, as timber prices often rise with economic growth.
• Risks:
  • Environmental risks, such as wildfires, pests (like bark beetles), or regulatory restrictions on harvesting.
  • Market fluctuations in timber prices.
  • Requires due diligence on the sustainability of the timber operation to ensure long-term value.

3. Water Rights

• What They Are: Water rights grant the owner the legal right to use or extract water from a specific source (e.g., a river, aquifer, or lake) for purposes like irrigation, industrial use, or municipal supply. In many regions, especially in the western U.S., water rights are separate from land ownership and can be bought, sold, or leased.
• Why They Qualify: Water rights are often classified as real property under state law and IRS guidelines, particularly when they are appurtenant to the land (i.e., tied to the property) or when they are perpetual in nature. For example, in states like Colorado or California, water rights are treated as real estate interests.
• How They’re Used in a 1031 Exchange: You can sell water rights and reinvest the proceeds into another like-kind real property. For instance, you might sell irrigation water rights in California’s Central Valley and exchange them for mineral rights in Nevada or a commercial property.
• Benefits:
  • Growing demand for water in arid regions, especially with climate change and population growth, can lead to appreciation.
  • Potential for steady income if the rights are leased to farmers, municipalities, or industrial users.
  • Unique asset class with low correlation to traditional real estate markets.
• Risks:
  • Highly regulated, with legal disputes common in water-scarce regions.
  • Value can be affected by drought, environmental regulations, or changes in water allocation policies.
  • State-specific laws vary, so eligibility for a 1031 exchange depends on how the rights are classified (e.g., perpetual rights are more likely to qualify than temporary permits).

4. Long-Term Leasehold Interests (with 30+ Years Remaining)

• What They Are: A leasehold interest is the right to use a property under a long-term lease, often for 30 years or more. For example, you might lease land from a government entity (like the Bureau of Land Management) or a private owner for 99 years to develop or operate a business.
• Why They Qualify: The IRS considers leasehold interests with 30 years or more remaining (including renewal options) as real property for 1031 exchange purposes. This is because a long-term lease is deemed to have the economic characteristics of ownership.
• How They’re Used in a 1031 Exchange: You can sell a long-term leasehold interest and exchange it for another real property. For example, you might sell a 50-year lease on a piece of land where you operate a solar farm and reinvest the proceeds into mineral rights or a traditional property.
• Benefits:
  • Access to valuable land without needing to buy it outright.
  • Often used for specialized projects like renewable energy, agriculture, or commercial development.
  • Can provide steady income if the lease allows for subleasing.
• Risks:
  • You don’t own the underlying land, so your rights are subject to the lease terms and the landowner’s actions.
  • If the lease term falls below 30 years, it may no longer qualify as real property for a 1031 exchange.
  • Potential disputes with the landowner over lease conditions or renewals.

5. Conservation Easements (with Perpetual Restrictions)

• What They Are: A conservation easement is a legal agreement that restricts the development of a piece of land to preserve its natural, agricultural, or historical value. For example, you might place a perpetual easement on a 200-acre farm to prevent it from being developed into a subdivision, while still retaining ownership of the land.
• Why They Qualify: The IRS treats certain interests in land, like perpetual conservation easements, as real property. When you sell a conservation easement, you’re essentially selling a portion of your property rights (the development rights), which can qualify for a 1031 exchange if reinvested into another real property.
• How They’re Used in a 1031 Exchange: You can sell a conservation easement and reinvest the proceeds into another like-kind real property. For instance, you might sell a $1 million conservation easement on a ranch in Montana and exchange it for timber rights in Washington.
• Benefits:
  • Potential for additional tax benefits, as donating a conservation easement can also qualify for charitable deductions (though this is separate from the 1031 exchange).
  • Preserves land for environmental or cultural purposes while unlocking value.
  • Can be a strategic way to monetize land without fully selling it.
• Risks:
  • Valuation of easements can be complex and subject to IRS scrutiny.
  • The market for easements may be limited, depending on the land’s location and conservation value.
  • Perpetual restrictions can reduce the land’s future flexibility for other uses.

Important Notes on Non-Real Estate Assets

• Post-2017 Restrictions: Before the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, 1031 exchanges could include personal property (e.g., swapping a private jet for a yacht, or a piece of machinery for another). Now, only real property qualifies, which excludes most alternative investments like stocks, bonds, cryptocurrencies, or collectibles (e.g., art, classic cars).
• Working Interests Don’t Qualify: In the context of oil and gas, a working interest (where you’re actively involved in operations and bear costs) is considered a business interest, not real property, and doesn’t qualify for a 1031 exchange. However, royalty interests (as discussed earlier) do qualify.
• IRS Definition of Real Property: The IRS defines real property for 1031 purposes as land and anything permanently affixed to it (e.g., buildings, inherent resources like minerals or timber). It also includes certain intangible rights tied to the land, like mineral rights, water rights, or long-term leaseholds.

Why Use These Alternatives in a 1031 Exchange?

• Diversification: Moving from one type of real property (e.g., a rental building) into an alternative like mineral rights or timber rights allows you to diversify your portfolio while deferring taxes.
• Passive Income: Many of these alternatives, like royalties or leaseholds, provide passive income without the management demands of traditional real estate.
• Specialized Opportunities: These assets can tap into niche markets (e.g., water rights in drought-prone areas, timber in growing construction markets) with potential for high returns.
• Tax Deferral: Like any 1031 exchange, you can defer capital gains taxes, keeping more capital working in your investments.

Challenges and Risks

• Valuation and Due Diligence: Assets like mineral rights, timber rights, or water rights require specialized appraisals and due diligence to assess their value and risks (e.g., resource depletion, regulatory changes).
• Market Volatility: Many of these assets are tied to commodity prices (e.g., oil, timber) or regional factors (e.g., water scarcity), which can be more volatile than traditional real estate.
• Liquidity: These investments are often illiquid, with limited markets for buying or selling compared to traditional real estate.
• Regulatory Complexity: State laws and federal regulations can complicate ownership and transfer, especially for water rights or conservation easements.
• IRS Compliance: The 1031 exchange rules (45-day identification, 180-day closing, use of a qualified intermediary) still apply, and the IRS may scrutinize whether the asset truly qualifies as real property.

Real-World Context

As of early 2025, investors are increasingly looking at alternative real property assets for 1031 exchanges due to high valuations in traditional real estate markets. For example, water rights in the western U.S. have become a hot commodity amid ongoing droughts, with some investors exchanging urban rental properties for water rights in California’s Central Valley. Similarly, timber rights in the Pacific Northwest have gained attention as lumber prices remain elevated due to housing demand.

In summary, while the 2017 tax law change limited 1031 exchanges to real property, alternative investment vehicles like mineral rights, timber rights, water rights, long-term leaseholds, and conservation easements can still qualify. They offer unique opportunities for diversification and tax deferral but come with specialized risks and complexities that require careful planning and professional guidance.

We love helping investors take the next step. Please don’t hesitate to call us – we have 1031 Specialists ready to answer your questions just one phone call away at (949) 328-6744.

If you’re ready to start looking at properties online, create an account below to get started: